Episodes 100
Avg. Duration 1h 15m
Activity Highly Active
Apple Rating 5.0 (139)
Since Apr 2021
Latest Episode Mar 2026

Outreach Signals

Open to Sponsors Features Guests

Publishing Details

Schedule
Every 2 Weeks
Format
Episodic
Consistency
65%
Hosting
catholicfeedback.libsyn.com

Contact & Outreach

About This Podcast

A podcast exploring faith, life and culture, hosted by former protestant pastor and Catholic convert Keith Nester. In this Podcast, Keith responds to questions and comments from listeners and shares his unique perspective. Check it out!

Social Media

Explore Statistics

Recent Episodes

Episode 146- From Drug Addiction to Christ | Tony Shriner's Conversion Story

Mar 05, 2026 2h 1m

From Drug Addiction to Christ | Tony Shriner's Conversion Story In this powerful interview, Keith Nester sits down with Tony Shriner, CEO of Mass of the Ages, to share his remarkable journey from a…

Episode 145- Eric Sammons on Conversion, Truth, and Leading Crisis Magazine

Feb 19, 2026 3h 4m

What leads a committed Christian to become Catholic? In this powerful conversation, Keith Nester sits down with Eric Sammons, editor of Crisis Magazine, to discuss his journey from Protestantism into…

Episode 144- TV Star Austin Peck Becomes Catholic!

Feb 04, 2026 1h 44m

TV star Austin Peck (Days of Our Lives, As the World Turns, Chicago Fire, etc.) shares his powerful conversion story from Protestant Christianity to Catholicism in this in-depth interview with Keith…

Episode 143- Evangelical Missionary → Catholic Iconographer | Garrett Hines' Conversion Story

Jan 21, 2026 2h

In this powerful interview, Keith Nester sits down with Garrett Hines, a former Evangelical missionary whose journey led him into the heart of the Catholic Church — and into the ancient, sacred art…

Episode 142- He Rejected God—Then Found the Catholic Church | Mike Elias

Jan 08, 2026 1h 35m

Mike was atheist-Jewish, then Buddhist/Taoist, and then Protestant before God showed him the truth about the Catholic faith. Now he runs a Catholic fashion company: https://HighGothicCasual.com In…

Episode 141- The Truth About Exodus 90 (From Founder Jamie Baxter)

Dec 31, 2025 1h 57m

What does real freedom actually look like for men today? In this powerful interview, Jamie Baxter, founder of Exodus 90, explains why discipline, prayer, asceticism, and brotherhood are essential for…

Episode 140- Catholic Conversion Essentials with Dr. Scott Hahn

Dec 02, 2025 1h 14m

Catholic Conversion Wisdom from the man himself! Today, Keith is joined by Dr. Scott Hahn at the St. Paul Center for Biblical Theology. https://stpaulcenter.com/ to discuss issues related to…

Episode 139- Cy Kellet (Catholic Answers)

Nov 20, 2025 1h 22m

Brought to you by Exodus 90 https://exodus90.com/ and The Catholic Woodworker https://catholicwoodworker.com/ 🎙️ Welcome to Catholic Feedback, the show where former Protestant pastor and Catholic…

Episode 138- He Was a Protestant Pastor Until He Discovered This...

Nov 05, 2025 2h 25m

🎙️ Welcome to Catholic Feedback, the show where former Protestant pastor and Catholic convert, Keith Nester, sits down with inspiring guests to discuss faith, conversion, Catholic life, and what it…

Episode 137- Jacksonville Mayor Becomes Catholic

Oct 21, 2025 1h 20m

Lenny Curry is the former Mayor of Jacksonville, Florida. A chance encounter with Brandon Forschino led this prominent politician on an amazing journey to the Catholic Church. You won't believe this…

Episode 136- Devin Schadt- "The Rule" for Catholic Men

Oct 17, 2025 1h 10m

Devin Schadt, founder of The Fathers of Saint Joseph, invites Keith into his home for a fascinating conversation about what it means to establish a Rule of life. https://fathersofstjoseph.org/ Get…

Episode 135- Dr. Jason Reed's Catholic Conversion

Sep 30, 2025 1h 50m

Dr. Jason Reed PHD joins Keith to share his catholic conversion story. Dr. Reed's website: https://www.reedthomist.com/ Join Keith on a pilgrimage to France! …

Episode 134 - Answering Tough Questions from Protestants w/Joe Heschmeyer

Sep 26, 2025 1h 13m

Catholic Answers Apologist Joe Heschmeyer joins Keith to discuss the state of Catholic Apologetics, what he thinks about answering the same arguments over and over and much more! Joe's YouTube: /…

Episode 133 - Evangelical Missionary is Fired for Becoming Catholic. Matt Selby's Conversion

Sep 20, 2025 1h 35m

Matt Selby is the Director of Adult and Marriage Formation for the Archdiocese of Dubuque. In this episode, Matt shares his incredible journey to the Catholic faith (including how he was fired from…

Episode 132 - Joelle Maryn's Illumination of Conscience

Sep 08, 2025 1h 23m

Joelle Maryn is an award-winning actress, international TV host, and one of America's top 100 keynote speakers. Joelle has modeled for many national brands, was on a billboard in Times Square, and…

Episode 131 - He Became Catholic and Gave it All Away- David Abel

Sep 02, 2025 51m

David Abel has an incredible story of freedom, healing, conversion, and redemption. This man has changed the lives of countless individuals through his generous support of numerous ministries and his…

Episode 130 - Why this 20-Year-Old Left Protestantism to Become Catholic

Aug 20, 2025 43m

Zoomer YouTuber Evan Raugust sits down with Keith to share his journey to Catholicism. Follow Evan here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmtg7MFzYouumRMjcO_efPQ Join Keith on a pilgrimage to France!…

Episode 129 - Mother Natalia's AMAZING Journey

Aug 06, 2025 1h 20m

Mother Natalia is an Eastern Rite Catholic Nun with the Christ the Bridegroom Monastery in NE Ohio. https://www.christthebridegroom.org/ "What God is Not" Podcast episode:…

Episode 128 - Fitness Legend Mike Pantile's Catholic Conversion

Jul 14, 2025 1h 54m

Mike Pantile is a popular fitness influencer and entrepreneur who shares his amazing journey to the Catholic faith with Keith. The next day, Mike deadlifted 705lbs at the St. Michael Barbell club. It…

Episode 127 - Fr. Chris Podhajsky- The Priest Who Made Me Catholic.

Jul 01, 2025 2h 12m

This episode is sponsored by The Augustine Institute. https://www.augustineinstitute.org/graduate-school/graduate-school Fr. Chris Podhajsky is the priest that Keith met with on his journey into the…

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does Catholic Feedback have?

Catholic Feedback has published 100 episodes since April 2021, covering topics in Christianity, Religion & Spirituality.

Is Catholic Feedback still active?

Catholic Feedback is currently highly active with new episodes every 2 weeks. Average episode length is 1h 15m.

How do I contact Catholic Feedback for sponsorship or guest appearances?

Sign up on Grep.FM to access contact details for Catholic Feedback, including email and social media links.

Similar Podcasts