Episodes 347
Avg. Duration 57m
Activity Highly Active
Apple Rating 4.7 (11,990)
Since May 2020
Latest Episode Jan 2026

Outreach Signals

Open to Sponsors Features Guests

Publishing Details

Schedule
Weekly
Format
Episodic
Consistency
70%
Hosting
feeds.megaphone.fm

Contact & Outreach

About This Podcast

From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappeared," you’ll love this new show from co-hosts and best friends Ellyn Marsh & Joey Taranto. Join Ellyn, Joey – and all the characters that live inside their gorgeous heads – for true stories and the campy television that covers them. Get ready to laugh, cry and think about true crime in a whole new way.

Explore Statistics

Recent Episodes

Episode 13 (Unsolved Mysteries)

Jan 28, 2026 1h 16m

A popular disc jockey is killed after a high-speed duel, and his murderer is still at large. A man vanishes from the side of a Pennsylvania highway. A 77-year-old Don Juan steals the hearts of his…

True Crime Rundown: Michael Proctor, Chad Franke & More

Jan 26, 2026 34m

On this week’s Rundown, Ellyn and Joey have a lot to cover. They discuss Chad Franke who broke his silence on his mom, Ruby Franke. Then they discuss Brendan Banfield who is expected to testify in…

Episode 12 (Unsolved Mysteries)

Jan 21, 2026 1h 10m

A Hungarian family searches for the American soldier that saved them decades ago. A man disappears after a late-night trip to an ATM in Los Angeles. A husband maintains his innocence in the death of…

True Crime Rundown: Pam Smart, Spencer and Monique Tepe & Aaron Spencer

Jan 19, 2026 38m

This week Ellyn is joined by special guest Mel Barrett while Joey is on vacation. Mel gives some big news about her involvement with Pam Smart and then also discusses the Aaron Spencer case. Ellyn…

Episode 11 (Unsolved Mysteries)

Jan 14, 2026 1h 10m

A husband found dead in a fire is found dead again 10 years later in another fire. A woman recovering from a coma has no memory of the attack or her attackers. A clumsy bank robber remains at large…

True Crime Rundown: Renee Nicole Good, Spencer & Monique Tepe, Nick Reiner

Jan 12, 2026 31m

On this week’s True Crime Rundown Ellyn gives a quick update on Nick Reiner and the status of his legal team. Then, they discuss Renee Nicole Good who was shot and killed by an ICE agent in…

Episode 10 (Unsolved Mysteries)

Jan 07, 2026 1h 14m

Charlie believes he has finally found happiness, but is killed after discovering his wife's infidelity. A family man walks away from his home and disappears. Numerous Americans blame their missing…

True Crime Rundown: Rob & Michele Reiner and Brian Walshe Sentencing

Jan 05, 2026 26m

We're back for the first Rundown of 2026. Ellyn and Joey cover the tragic murders of Rob and Michele Reiner. They also discuss Brian Walshe's recent sentencing. Learn more about your ad choices.…

Bonus from Patreon - Swagg Man (Smugshot)

Dec 31, 2025 56m

As part of our dark week due to the holiday, we have a special surprise for you all! This is a bonus episode, previously exclusive to our Patreon page and originally published on 10/27/25. Join now…

Bonus from Patreon - The Getaway (Smugshot)

Dec 24, 2025 53m

As part of our dark week due to the holiday, we have a special surprise for you all! This is a bonus episode, previously exclusive to our Patreon page and originally published on 10/30/25. Join now…

Episode 9 (Unsolved Mysteries)

Dec 17, 2025 1h 6m

A teen disappears, only to be found dead days later with no apparent cause of death. Two boys have a run of good luck after discovering a mysterious rock. Authorities fear a priest killer may be on…

True Crime Rundown: Karen Read and Brian Walshe Updates & More

Dec 15, 2025 27m

Welcome to True Crime Rundown. This week, Joey dives in to a Karen Read update as well as the story of Mary Carole McDonnell, a true crime TV Producer who has been added to the FBI's Most Wanted…

Episode 8 (Unsolved Mysteries)

Dec 10, 2025 1h 14m

A convicted murderer fashions an improbable escape from San Quentin State Prison. A husband searches for his missing wife, but must answer allegations he is responsible. A small town hero may also be…

True Crime Rundown: Luigi Mangione & Brian Walshe

Dec 08, 2025 31m

On this week's True Crime Rundown Joey starts by updating on Luigi Mangione and the state's case. Will they have his charges thrown out because they forgot to read Miranda rights? Not like we…

Episode 7 (Unsolved Mysteries)

Dec 03, 2025 1h 6m

New evidence in the Son of Sam shootings suggest that the killer was part of a satanic cult. A waitress at an inn in Pennsylvania sees the spirit of a Revolutionary War soldier. A wealthy woman is…

True Crime Rundown: Kelsey Fitzsimmons & Minerliz "Minnie" Soriano

Dec 01, 2025 38m

This week on True Crime Rundown, Ellyn and Joey discuss Kelsey Fitzsimmons who pleaded not guilty to a charge of assault with a dangerous weapon. Her trial was recently set for February. They then…

Bonus from Patreon: Unknown Number: The High School Catfish

Nov 26, 2025 1h

As part of our dark week due to the holiday, we have a special surprise for you all! This is a bonus episode, previously exclusive to our Patreon and Apple Subscription pages and originally published…

True Crime Rundown: Karen Read and Anna Kepner

Nov 24, 2025 29m

This week's True Crime Rundown covers all of the most recent updates on Karen Read. Then, Ellyn and Joey also discuss the cause of death of Anna Kepner, who was found dead on a Carnival cruise ship…

Episode 6 (Unsolved Mysteries)

Nov 19, 2025 1h 11m

A man is arrested for the Son of Sam killings in New York, but some believe he may not have acted alone. A deacon and his wife are the victims of a double murder in Georgia. A frugal bachelor leaves…

True Crime Rundown: Diddy, Randy Cox, & Epstein/Maxwell

Nov 17, 2025 32m

This week on True Crime Rundown, Ellyn and Joey discuss Ghislaine Maxwell as well as the recently released Epstein emails. Then, they dive into updates on Diddy's prison sentence. They also cover the…

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does I Think Not! have?

I Think Not! has published 347 episodes since May 2020, covering topics in Comedy, Society & Culture.

Is I Think Not! still active?

I Think Not! is currently highly active with new episodes weekly. Average episode length is 57m.

How do I contact I Think Not! for sponsorship or guest appearances?

Sign up on Grep.FM to access contact details for I Think Not!, including email and social media links.

Similar Podcasts