Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia
Hailey and Holly
Key Metrics
About the Show
Partnership & Audience Signals
267 episodes — long track record
Production & Distribution
Feed Capabilities Podcasting 2.0
Advanced RSS tags in this feed — signals for transcripts, dynamic ad insertion, and analytics support.
Recent Episodes
The Giggling Granny Part 2
Join us this week for the conclusion of the Giggling Granny case. Support the show
The Giggling Granny Part 1
Join us this month for the case of the giggling Granny. Is she a sweet old lady that has experienced so much tragedy or a cold blooded killer?Support the show
Twelve Tribes Pt. 2
Join us for part 2 of our discussion on the twelve tribes. Support the show
Twelve Tribes Pt. 1
Join us this week as we talk about a group operating in Appalachia, specifically along the Appalachian trail. Are they a cult or just a friendly group of like minded people? Support the show
Mamie Thurman Pt. 2
Part 2 of the Maimee Thurman case! Support the show
Mamie Thurman Pt. 1
Y'all this episode may be cursed! We lost the original audio, rerecorded on zoom, and Hailey's computer almost bit the dust. This is one of the most interesting cases we have covered in a while so…
Anjette Lyles
This month we discuss female serial killer Anjette Lyles. Whatever you do, don't let her make you a drink. Support the show
The Brinkley College Ghost
Join us for this months episode about Brinkley College. We discuss its history and its hauntings! Support the show
ANNOUNCEMENT!!!!!
AHHHHH!!!!! We are taking a leap! Listen in to hear about our new project! Support the show
The Lizard Man
Happy 5 year anniversary to us!!! Thank you all for joining us for this weeks episode as we talk about the legend of the Lizard man. Support the show
Mary Shotwell Little Part 2
Join us for the final part of the Mary Shotwell Little story.Support the show
Mary Shotwell Little Part 1
This week we dive into the disappearance of Mary Shotwell Little.Support the show
The Signal Mountain Murders
Join us this week as we discuss a triple homicide out of Tennessee. Support the show
Baby in the Closet
Join us as we discuss a developing case out of Kentucky. Support the show
The Case of LaLurie
Join us this week for another case from Hailey's travels to New Orleans. We discuss the horrific case of LaLurie. Support the show
The Alford Plea
Join us this week as we talk about the case that brought about the Alford Plea. Support the show
Jazz it Out
Join us this week as we take it to New Orleans to discuss the axeman murders in the early 1900s.Support the show
Kidnapped from a Fire
Join us this week for a new episode! Support the show
The Ogua River Monster
Join us this week as we discuss a cryptid from the great state of West Virginia! Support the show
What Happened to the Children
Join us this week for a new mystery!Support the show
Market Reports
Benchmark this show against its category and language peers.
Similar Podcasts
Comparable shows in the same category and language — useful for prospecting and competitive sets.
An Old Timey Podcast
An Old Timey Podcast
107 episodes
Ridiculous Crime
iHeartPodcasts
460 episodes
Housewives of True Crime
Tabitha Kane
399 episodes
Cult Podcast
Paige Wesley & Armando Torres
378 episodes
Those Conspiracy Guys
Gordon Rochford
209 episodes
CrimeLess
iHeartPodcasts and Smartless Media
44 episodes
Profile compiled from public podcast metadata · Last refreshed June 15, 2026